3 reasons your Nonprofit might be stuck (and how to fix it)



How Small Nonprofits Accidentally Stall Their Own Growth

Read time: 3-4 minutes

Most nonprofit leaders are working incredibly hard, but sometimes, even the most dedicated teams can accidentally get in their own way.

The tricky part? These patterns are hard to spot when you're in the middle of them. You're showing up every day, working hard, caring deeply about your mission, and yet…Progress feels slower than it should. The to-do list never gets shorter.

If that sounds familiar, you're not alone. These patterns are incredibly common among small, growing nonprofits. They're not a sign that something is wrong with you or your organization. They're just common traps that are easy to fall into – BUT even easier to fix once you know what to look for. 👀

In this week's Changemaker Mondays ☀️ ☕ 🌍, I'm sharing three stall patterns I see small nonprofits get stuck in, along with simple fixes to help you break through them and start moving forward again.

Changemaker Mondays is brought to you by:

Strong donor relationships are the backbone of your nonprofit’s success - but keeping supporters engaged takes ongoing effort. That’s where our sponsor, Click & Pledge, comes in. Their platform makes it simple to cultivate donors and encourage giving online, all at a price point built for nonprofits.

With Click & Pledge, you’ll get professional-grade tools to power your fundraising, including customizable peer-to-peer campaign pages, donor portals for managing accounts and transactions, text-to-give options, and even virtual event and video fundraising. Plus, their guides and templates help you launch successful campaigns during giving season and beyond.
​

Best of all, every feature is included—no contracts, no hidden add-on fees. And unlike other platforms, Click & Pledge’s pricing stays the same whether you have 10 donors or 10,000.

👉 Use the link to book a demo and get your first $25 monthly fee waived!

Stall Pattern 1: Operating in Reactive Mode

When every day feels like putting out fires, it's really hard to move forward. You spend your time responding to emails, handling last-minute requests, and jumping from one urgent thing to the next.

Before you know it, the week is over, and the big picture work, the strategy, the planning, the relationship building, never happened. And it suuuuucks.

This is the reactive mode.

The fix: This sounds like a small thing but it was a game changer for me – Block 2-3 hours per week specifically for planning and strategy. Put it on your calendar like a meeting you can't cancel and protect that block of time like a mama bear protecting her cubs. Let folks know you are unavailable and unreachable during that time. Use that time to think ahead, work on your fundraising plan, or map out your next program.

Stall Pattern 2: Doing Too Many Things at Once

It's easy to say yes to everything when you care deeply about your mission. A new program idea here. A special event there. Another initiative that sounds really promising. Before long, your team is stretched thin, nothing is getting the attention it deserves, and everything feels halfway done.

Doing too many things at once doesn't just burn out your team; it also undermines your team's effectiveness. It actually slows your growth because nothing ever fully develops, streamlines, or scales.

The organizations that grow the fastest aren't doing the most things. They're doing the right things really well.

The fix: Choose 1-2 priorities and go deep. Decide what they should be based on what’s gaining traction and most effectively moving your work forward. Resist the urge to add more until those things are running smoothly and have clear systems behind them. Focus is not a limitation. It's a growth strategy.

Stall Pattern 3: No Clear System to Turn Interest Into Support

People are finding your organization. They're following you on social media, visiting your website, maybe even showing up to an event. But then the connection fades. They don't end up donating, volunteering, or staying engaged. 😐

This is one of the most frustrating stall patterns because the interest is there. The problem is that there is no clear path guiding people from curiosity to commitment.

There’s some kind of invisible bottleneck – so we’ve got to tackle that.

The fix: Find the bottleneck by mapping out your audience journey. Here's a simple way to start:

  1. Awareness: How do people first find you? Social media, word of mouth, events?
  2. Interest: What do you offer them next? A newsletter signup, a follow, a free resource?
  3. Engagement: How do you keep them connected? Regular updates, volunteer opportunities, events?
  4. Action: What's the clear ask? Donate, volunteer, or become a recurring supporter?

When you can see the full journey, you can spot exactly where people are falling off and fix it.

Ready to Break Through Your Stall Patterns?

If any of these patterns hit close to home, I want you to know there's a place where we work through exactly this kind of stuff together.

The Changemaker Accelerator is my private membership community for nonprofit and social impact leaders who are ready to stop spinning their wheels and start making progress. We've got dozens of templates and tools, extra courses, peer discussions, and monthly group coaching where we cover everything from fundraising and strategy to marketing and leadership.

​Enrollment is open right now, and we'd love to see you there!

Try it this week 🚀

Pick one of these three stall patterns and ask yourself, " Is this showing up in my organization right now?” Then take one small step toward fixing it this week. You don't have to solve everything at once. Just start with one thing.

​
​

💲Funding Opportunities

  • Rolling: Complete the Eligibility quiz, and submit your LOI to be considered for a proposal invitation by the Pincus Family Foundation. Award locations are focused on the Northeast U.S., as well as Louisiana, California, and New Mexico. Areas of interest include education; creative and performing arts; play and recreation; health and wellness. Funds may be approved for various purposes, including operating costs, research, and pilot programs!
  • Reviewing September and December: The Cogir Foundation supports causes within the states where they operate (see map) that promote wellbeing for young people and seniors, including enrichment themes promoting education and active lifestyles; or preserving mental and physical health.
  • Due by September 1: The Bolger Foundation provides grants (range: $10,000-$250,000) for nonprofit capital projects supporting conservation and preservation, the underprivileged and underserved, education, and health. Funds may be used to build "tangible property," ranging from constructing a facility to purchasing "significant and long-lasting equipment."

📅

Events & Programs

​
Keep an eye out for future workshops and events open to the public! In the mean time, need an event speaker or workshop trainer? Learn more about my workshops and other services.

Enjoy this week's newsletter? You might find this video helpful, too.
​

3 more ways I can help you

  1. I have lots of free content for you! Check out my library of 450+ educational videos on nonprofits, social entrepreneurship, fundraising, and more on my YouTube channel. If you like what I'm trying to do, help me reach more people like you by subscribing to the channel and sharing it with a changemaker friend! 😁
    ​
  2. Need extra support to build or grow a nonprofit or social enterprise? Check out my Changemaker Accelerator membership or my Zero to $100,000 Fundraising Starter Toolkit.
    ​
  3. Need a speaker or training workshop for your social impact event? I'm currently booking 2026-2027 speaking engagements -- check out my speaking and workshop opportunities to learn how I can help you make your event inspiring and actionable!

Hey, Changemaker!

I'm Amber, writer of the Changemaker Mondays newsletter! I'm a nonprofit founder, speaker, and social entrepreneur on a mission to equip you with the tools you need to create positive change where ever you live -- whether you're starting a nonprofit or socially-conscious business, looking for a social impact job, or leading a volunteer project in your city. Don't hesitate to connect (socials below), or reply to this email if you ever have any feedback on how we can make Changemaker Mondays the best newsletter for supporting changemakers in the world!

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Amber Melanie Smith

I am on a mission to equip nonprofit and social impact changemakers with the tools and resources to grow their impacts. Join me and over 80,000 changemakers on my social impact-focused YouTube channel at https://www.youtube.com/ambermelaniesmith!

Read more from Amber Melanie Smith

Want to build a loyal donor base? Start with these 5 questions. Read time: 3-4 minutes The secret to building a loyal donor base? It starts with a great conversation. Before someone becomes a committed donor, they need to feel connected to your mission, your community, and the problem you're working to solve. The best way to build that connection? Ask the right questions… and truly listen to the answers. Understanding where a potential donor is in their journey, what they care about, and what...

Your Nonprofit Is Growing. Are Your Systems Keeping Up? Read time: 3-4 minutes Can I tell you something that every growing nonprofit leader eventually figures out? When your organization is small, it is totally normal for a lot of things to live in one person's head. Maybe that's even you. You know where everything is, you remember every deadline, and you can answer almost any question on the spot. But here is what happens as your team grows: Things start slipping through the cracks. People...

The Changemaker's Confidence Curve: Overcoming Imposter Syndrome as a Nonprofit Leader Read time: 3-4 minutes I can’t tell you the number of times in the past where I sat in a meeting or looked at another organization's amazing website or Instagram, and thought to myself, "Do I actually know what I’m doing?" If, like me, you’ve ever been tapped on the shoulder by the Imposter Syndrome Gremlin 👾 -- I want you to know two things:1) You are not alone. And…2) These feelings probably don’t mean...